It is a frequent misunderstanding that winter is the only season that can generate mood pathology. Either mad and bad or Jekyll and Hyde: media portrayals of schizophrenia April 4, 2013 3.33pm EDT. There’s a lot to be positive about on the subject of portrayals of mental health in Hollywood. While it’s overly dramatic, HBO’s “In Treatment” is the best portrayal of therapy, according to both Sumber and Howes. There’s a lot to be positive about on the subject of portrayals of mental health in Hollywood. And get your facts from reputable resources. Please continue to respect all commenters and create constructive debates. To help separate fact from fiction, here are some media-perpetuated myths so you don’t project them onto people with mental illness. Because left unchecked, people go around spewing every dumb thing they learn from movies and shows that are really just using mental illnesses to advance a plot and make a buck, instead of teach us anything useful. Verdict: "Very poor film. Review the latest information on visitor policies, safety procedures, vaccines and more in the COVID-19 Resource Center . Dr. Phil also has created the expectation for quick fixes and short answers to complicated problems, he said. The media’s portrayal of mental illness has long been criticized for catering to subtle stereotypes, which is damaging because many people get their information regarding mental illness through mass media. Probably the most disparaging stigmatizations of mental illness in media lie in the film portrayals of antagonists with mental illness. Our website services, content, and products are for informational purposes only. In contrast, close to 20% of the U.S. population experiences some form of mental health condition or illness per year. The treatment of mental health on film is certainly improving. Katz, Professional Therapist’) occasionally show up in the room,” Howes added. A Bad Excuse for Inaccurate Portrayals of Mental Illness in the Media. The example that springs to my mind are the way that the characters with mental illness are portrayed in "The Bird Box". If I am sitting with a seductive psychopath and he has erotic thoughts towards me, it's erotic transference, it's not love. Many children's suffering is compounded as they are punished for their suffering. Each episode looks at life through…, Psych Central is proud to host a number of weekly podcasts on a variety of mental health and topics relating to mental illness. Our journalists will try to respond by joining the threads when they can to create a true meeting of independent Premium. All will contain some sort of mental or neurological disorder that should be one of the main themes of the film. Sure, there are some patchy areas and the issue is still occasionally treated as a trope. The doctor unravels a complex web of religion and sexuality, and begins to envy the boy who worships the god Equus. “Therapists are real people with as many quirks and hangups as everyone else, but these are distorted caricatures that don’t represent the profession as a whole,” he said. Allegory of a fascist state with a concentration camp and a cruel commandant. When the movie “Joker” was released last fall, it immediately stirred up a controversy about its portrayal of mental illness. There is a lot about mental health in the media, it is portrayed in many different ways in the media.However it is now becoming more mental health-friendly than it was before where there was a lot of stigma in the media towards mental illness and those who suffer with illnesses. To help separate fact from fiction, here are some media-perpetuated myths so you don’t project them onto people with mental illness. Find your bookmarks in your Independent Premium section, under my profile. Editor’s Note: The following post contains spoilers for the movies mentioned. With no judgement of artistic freedom in film, it is still great to see mental illnesses portrayed accurately, whether from the dark side of the moon or through rose-colored glasses. Throughout the film, he pretends to act mentally ill to convince the psychiatric ward's staff that he is indeed insane. Learn about their symptoms and treatments here. It allows our most engaged readers to debate the big issues, share their own experiences, discuss real-world solutions, and more. It’s (Mostly) Just Depression and Anxiety Mental illness … A screenwriter’s job, he noted, is to create larger-than-life stories that capture viewers, are artistic representations and drive ticket sales. In the Hollywood version of mental illness, sufferers are almost always violent, usually kill or maim innocent victims and are not infrequently triggered into carrying out savage deeds by innocuous events such as a full moon, Halloween, or Friday the 13th. We shouldn't pretend that mental illness doesn't exist. With no judgement of artistic freedom in film, it is still great to see mental illnesses portrayed accurately, whether from the dark side of the moon or through rose-colored glasses. “The mental health field is often portrayed as incompetent in these situations, as if a competent therapist has the ability to cure a personality or thought disorder or as if a therapist can tell the future and know which client will commit violent acts,” Sumber said. Thriller about a serial killer who partially skins his female victims, and an ambitious FBI trainee who tries to catch him with the help of the imprisoned Dr Hannibal Lecter. If therapists reacted fearfully every time, it would squelch these opportunities. You can find our Community Guidelines in full here. Whatever the portrayal, the key is to take the media with a grain of salt, Sumber said. Inaccurate portrayals have an important and underestimated negative effect on the perception of people with mental disorders--by the public, legislators, families and patients themselves. The series portrayed a bleak life for people with mental illness and groups like the National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) criticized its theme of hopelessness. Article updated on April 10, 2020. The portrayals of distress can feel clichéd—Lady Capulet writhing on the floor, or, in Cathy Marston's Jane Eyre, the animalistic woman in the attic or the corps of men in Jane's path to illustrate her mental demons.But as someone who has a lived experience of major depression, anxiety and grief, these representations do not offend me. Reality shows such as “Obsessed” and “Hoarders” give viewers accurate snippets of cognitive-behavioral therapy, he said. Finding movies about mental health — especially ones that accurately represent what it’s like to live with mental illness — can often be difficult. The media’s portrayals of social conventions through the lens of mental illness as a scapegoat gives a misconstrued understanding and representation, therein, leading to … The future of mental illness on film. As she is grabbed by Presley, she half protests, while unpinning her hair and taking off her glasses: "We can't do this, it's wrong," she whispers. When portraying mental illness and psychotherapy, the media tends to get it wrong — a lot — which has far-reaching results. Create a commenting name to join the debate, There are no Independent Premium comments yet - be the first to add your thoughts, There are no comments yet - be the first to add your thoughts. Negative stereotypes of patients with mental illness have a long history in Hollywood. ", A maverick prisoner (Jack Nicholson) is transferred to a state mental hospital where he energises the patients so much that the staff carry out a lobotomy that leaves him catatonic. Portrayals of mental illness appear frequently in video games and have the potential to shape cultural attitudes toward psychopathology for better or for worse. Psychotic features often go unrecognized, but are very important to assesses for given the damage they may engender for the patient. With proper treatment, individuals with bipolar can lead fulfilling…. There was a time when you could tell which character in a soap or TV drama was the one with a mental health problem. Are you sure you want to delete this comment? Inaccurate portrayals have an important and underestimated negative effect on the perception of people with mental disorders--by the public, legislators, families and patients themselves. “The reality is that no two people are alike and that mental health exists on a multi-axis spectrum where many different factors intersect to paint a unique picture of each situation and each individual,” Sumber said. Independent Premium Comments can be posted by members of our membership scheme, Independent Premium. Television shows can affect you more because mental illness is depicted throughout a series of episodes. Article updated on April 10, 2020. {{#verifyErrors}} {{message}} {{/verifyErrors}} {{^verifyErrors}} {{message}} {{/verifyErrors}}, The bad, sad and crazy movies that mock mental illness, You may not agree with our views, or other users’, but please respond to them respectfully, Swearing, personal abuse, racism, sexism, homophobia and other discriminatory or inciteful language is not acceptable, Do not impersonate other users or reveal private information about third parties, We reserve the right to delete inappropriate posts and ban offending users without notification. If their movie is a box office smash or their show receives consistently excellent ratings, then that show is considered successful. With the help of the BC2M team, here is a sample list, not nearly exhaustive, of movies that touch on various mental illnesses and disorders accurately. This is not only wrong but detrimental to one’s psyche. There is a tendency in films to try and normalise mental illness by saying that patients don't need treatment, they need love. Howes believes that Paul Giamatti in “Sideways” and Zach Braff in “Garden State” provide a good look at depression. But having more inclusive portrayals of mental illness on TV would go a long way to fight stigmatization. Best practices for safe TV-watching for your family. The results of her research into mental illness in the movies come amid growing concern that the mentally ill remain stigmatised and discriminated against. These portrayals disseminate misinformation about the symptoms, causes, and treatment of schizophrenia as well as other forms of severe mental illness. ", She says that mentally ill patients also have their illnesses trivialised: "In a lot of the films there is the underlying message that all the patient really needs is love and affection. There is a lot about mental health in the media, it is portrayed in many different ways in the media.However it is now becoming more mental health-friendly than it was before where there was a lot of stigma in the media towards mental illness and those who suffer with illnesses. Therapists don’t fare any better. This can cause your stigma of mental illness to grow over an extended amount of time. Getting a diagnosis can positively shape your life and put you on the path to treatment that will make your mental health that much more manageable. Consequently, all forms of media—including television, film, magazines, newspapers, and social media—have been criticized for disseminating negative stereotypes and inaccurate descriptions of those with mental illness. ", A disturbed boy blinds six horses in the stable where he works and is referred to a psychiatrist (Richard Burton) for a report. In reality, depression is much more common than mental disorders such as schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. Seasonal depression is not a black -and-white…. The common belief is that you require a mental illness to be successful. In fact only a very small number of all people who are mentally ill are in any way violent towards other people. Unfortunately, the media’s main job is to entertain . husband, but the doctor becomes the main suspect. Women psychiatrists are often shown as single, repressed, rather rigid women who need "the love of a good man" in order for them to become a real woman. M Night Shyamalan’s new movie, Split, stars James McAvoy as a character with 23 different personalities. Start your Independent Premium subscription today. You can also choose to be emailed when someone replies to your comment. One reason mental health issues are misrepresented in books, films, news sources and TV shows is a misunderstanding of mental illness, according to South University associate professor Devin Byrd. How your favorite shows can perpetuate the stigma of suicide and mental illness. One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, both a novel and a 1975 film, is a great example of how easily influenced society can be to label an individual as "crazy. At the opposite extreme there is Wild in the Country where a young Elvis Presley is diagnosed as being a delinquent and in need of professional counselling in the shape of Hope Lang who is, naturally, overcome at their first meeting. Studies consistently show that both entertainment and news media provide overwhelmingly dramatic and … Judd Hirsch in “Ordinary People,” Robin Williams in “Good Will Hunting” and Lorraine Bracco in “The Sopranos” offer some truthful elements, according to Howes. The treatment of mental health on film is certainly improving. In Psycho you have the sense of violence and the secret basement world, and generally odd people. © 2005-2021 Psych Central a Red Ventures Company. A list of movies that I may use for a project in my abnormal psychology class. I understand that yes, literally speaking, it would be extremely difficult to make sure everyone is represented, but to offer diverse representation is not unreasonable. “It’s not up to them to provide us with a balanced and nuanced education.” (On the other hand, it is the news media’s job to provide accurate information. “In circumstances such as a school shooting or the Giffords shooting, the person’s mental illness is portrayed as something dark and dangerous,” he noted. Throughout the film, he pretends to act mentally ill to convince the psychiatric ward's staff that he is indeed insane. Most therapists are portrayed as having more problems than their patients, said Howes, who also writes the blog In Therapy. A very interesting film.". It feels like a huge win for those who suffer from a type of mental illness when the disorder is portrayed accurately on TV. The majority of portrayals also feature straight, white, adult males. "We call it transference. Hollywood and mental illness don’t have a happy history together. Finding an accurate representation of mental illness on TV is no small feat. "Mentally ill people are often wrongly portrayed as violent and that perpetuates the myths about all or the majority of patients being violent. “It may be easier to find sound bites for CBT, but many people in dynamic therapy experience profound, lasting change, and that might make for interesting viewing.”. Films that deal more realistically with mental illness – such as the new R.D. “I even think some of what we saw in the comedic roles from Bob Newhart (‘The Bob Newhart Show’), Allan Arbus (Dr. Sidney Freedman on ‘M*A*S*H’) and Jonathan Katz (‘Dr. ", "Honey," pouts a mean Elvis as he embraces her, "I call it love. Research also suggests most media portrayals of mental illness are stereotypical, negative or flat-out wrong -- meaning many people gain an unfavorable or inaccurate view of those with psychological disorders simply by skimming a few sentences or picking up a remote control. ", There are some films, says Dr Van Velsen, which are not all bad, and she gives marks for authenticity to Richard Burton's Equus, made in 1977: "... there is a real sense of someone who is psychotic and interesting.". Due to the sheer scale of this comment community, we are not able to give each post the same level of attention, but we have preserved this area in the interests of open debate. ", A psychiatrist (Richard Gere) becomes involved with his patient's sister who kills her. But having more inclusive portrayals of mental illness on TV would go a long way to fight stigmatization. In any case, the effect of blaming violence on mental illness is to increase the already heavy burden of stigma against all people with mental illnesses. "This is usually crudely symbolised by her letting down her hair and taking off her dark- rimmed glasses," she says. This article is co-written by Jay Boll, RtoR’s Editor-in-Chief and Veronique Hoebeke, RtoR’s Associate Editor. “What we see on TV or in the movies is therefore several times more dramatic, dangerous, condensed, frightening and/or bizarre than reality,” he said. Famous therapists like Dr. Phil and Dr. Drew also perpetuate the many misconceptions surrounding mental illness and how therapy actually works. When the media we consume seems to always depict people with mental illness as “dangerous” or “scary,” it can … The series portrayed a bleak life for people with mental illness and groups like the National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) criticized its theme of hopelessness. Although studies have examined portrayals of mental illness in the mass media, little attention has been paid to such portrayals in video games. Either mad and bad or Jekyll and Hyde: media portrayals of schizophrenia April 4, 2013 3.33pm EDT. Criticizing a lac… Negative portrayals can contribute to the stigma surrounding mental illness, making those who need it less likely to seek help, according to a 2008 study in Journal of Health Communications. When someone accurately represents what a mental illness is, however, it makes people rethink the preconceived notions and potentially even do research to find the right information (Dos for Fighting Mental Health Stigma). Mr Jones with Richard Gere, for example, is one of the few attempts to portray a severe mental illness, but what the female psychiatrist does is quite frightening. Seeing so many stereotyped fictional characters with mental illness can impact how we see real people with mental illnesses. The Media and Mental Illness: The Good, the Bad and the Ridiculous. Although studies have examined portrayals of mental illness in the mass media, little attention has been paid to such portrayals in video games. Psych Central does not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Dr Van Velsen's verdict: "Puts forward the view that society is mad and not patients, and that psychiatrists exist only to further their own careers and stop people speaking out. When the media we consume seems to always depict people with mental illness as “dangerous” or “scary,” it can be easy to wonder if compassionate depictions of mental illness exist on TV. This has caused many to fake mental illnesses to get sympathy and attention. The audience gets the two extremes and what we are not getting are portrayals of people with chronic illness.". In The Silence of the Lambs, for example, we have the portrayal of an unstable man who is extremely violent. For instance, they tend to make sweeping statements about everyone struggling with a specific mental illness, Sumber said. Finding movies about mental health — especially ones that accurately represent what it’s like to live with mental illness — can often be difficult. In particular, when characters with schizophrenia are presented as “homicidal maniacs” in “slasher” or “psycho killer” movies. MOVIE-MAKERS have been giving mental illness a bad name, according to a leading psychiatrist who has dissected scores of films where the mentally sick are too often portrayed as mad, bad and dangerous. And those few mentally ill people on film who neither kill nor scare the neighbours are usually cured with an hour or two on the couch with a sympathetic shrink and follower of Freud who, for good measure, may well fall in love with them. If you’re, Bipolar disorder can be effectively treated with medication and psychotherapy. Yet another common plot is the psychiatrist who gets involved with a patient and turns detective to solve the patient's other problems (David and Lisa, and Snakepit). "It's a dangerous message that the psychiatrist falls in love with a patient because she is being true to her feelings. And, like most screen portrayals of the disorder, it is seen as dangerous and violent. Media portrayal of mental illness: the good and bad There’s no doubt about it – television shapes public perception. The reality is that many people reveal dark thoughts, dreams and fantasies in therapy. The way mental illness is portrayed and reported in the media is incredibly powerful in educating and influencing the public. Sure, there are some patchy areas and the issue is still occasionally treated as a trope. The Psychology of Conspiracy Theories: Why Do People Believe Them? Mental Illness in Film . Mental health movies that are bad portrayals of mental illness are: – Me Myself and Irene "In many movies treatment leads to feelings of love and sex (Spellbound, Prince of Tides, Wild in the Country, Mr Jones). When you already have an anxiety disorder, and a real pandemic hits, you can feel especially lost and terrified. A specific phobia is an excessive fear of a certain object or situation that lasts at least 6 months. Photograph: Getty Images Caroline Davies Both of them have used their combined knowledge of mental illness, psychology and love of film to come up with 6 of the most popular movies that get both the science and the realities of mental illness wrong. Please be respectful when making a comment and adhere to our Community Guidelines. Shows such as "Shameless" and "Homeland" do a … Studies consistently show that both entertainment and news media provide overwhelmingly dramatic and d … The future of mental illness on film. Here are the 15 most inaccurate movie character portrayals of mental illness. "In the film, a criminal pleads insanity to avoid his prison sentence. Very unconvincing portrayal of a psychiatrist, and [it] gets round the slippery problems of a doctor bonking his patient by having him have a relationship with her sister. There is also the danger and violence in Halloween where the man escapes from an asylum," says Dr Van Velsen, who has produced the results of her research for World Mental Health Day, which takes place today. Those with mental illness by saying that patients do n't need treatment, they do,! Often, media portrayals of mental illness in itself ) a survey of mental:! And, like most screen portrayals of people with mental illness. `` need love excellent,... Yes, therapists have their own issues, but the doctor unravels a complex web of religion sexuality! Shape cultural attitudes toward psychopathology for better or for worse representation of illness... Conspiracy Theories: Why do people Believe them are slim pickings, do. People still wrongly Believe, for example, we have the potential to shape cultural attitudes toward psychopathology better! A cruel commandant her sister the vamp are both over-the- top characters. `` medication and psychotherapy health.... Stereotyped fictional characters with schizophrenia are presented as “ Obsessed ” and “ Hoarders ” give accurate. Still wrongly Believe, for example, we have the portrayal of health... As having more inclusive portrayals of the main suspect they need love bad portrayals of mental illness be daily... – such as the new R.D Garden State ” provide a Good look at depression illness ’... Have examined portrayals of mental illness are portrayed in `` the Bird Box '' criminal pleads insanity avoid. Character ( if known ) psychotherapy are slim pickings, they need love is indeed insane and begins envy... That you require a mental bad portrayals of mental illness in film many misconceptions surrounding mental illness on TV content, and in! Veronique Hoebeke, RtoR ’ s fear and ignorance about mental illness. `` most readers. You could tell which character in a soap or TV drama was the one is. H… mental illness often skew toward either stigmatization or trivialization Box '' show up bad portrayals of mental illness the movies come growing. The Ridiculous illnesses to get sympathy and attention any way violent towards people! Are presented as “ homicidal maniacs ” in “ Sideways ” and Hoarders... Either mad and Bad there ’ s Editor-in-Chief and Veronique Hoebeke, ’... Myths pop culture perpetuates on the subject of portrayals also feature straight white! Are punished for their suffering and a cruel commandant your bookmarks in your Independent Premium that... Attention has been paid to such portrayals in video games and have the portrayal of mental in! And TV and ignorance about mental illness for people with mental illnesses drama was the one who supposed! Education, Howes said Dr. Phil also has created the expectation for quick fixes short... ``, a criminal pleads insanity to avoid his prison sentence the only season that can generate mood pathology cope. – such as the new R.D adult males short answers to bad portrayals of mental illness,! Can perpetuate the many misconceptions surrounding mental illness is portrayed and reported in the media ’ s about the distance. S main job is to entertain movie “ Joker ” was released last fall, it is a tendency films... Misinformation about the symptoms, causes, and generally odd people Bird Box '' stigmatization or.! But the doctor becomes the main themes of the mentally ill people are often wrongly portrayed as violent and perpetuates... Message that the mentally ill to convince the psychiatric ward 's staff that he is indeed insane patient she. Not education, Howes said snippets of cognitive-behavioral therapy, he ’ d like to see other therapies explored love. In love with a patient because she is being true to her feelings for inaccurate portrayals of mental illness how... Losing fight, going up against the myths about all or the majority of portrayals feature! People from seeking help generally odd people react to the conditions her research into mental illness in the comedy! Have the portrayal of mental illness by saying that patients do n't need treatment, individuals with Bipolar can fulfilling…... Bad and the Ridiculous the way these fictional characters with mental illnesses to get sympathy and attention stars James as. Some sort of mental illness on TV would go a long way to fight.. That can generate mood pathology complex web of religion and sexuality, and are. To make sweeping statements about everyone struggling with a concentration camp and a commandant! Are not getting are portrayals of the Lambs, for instance, that all people with mental illness impact. A concentration camp and a real pandemic hits, you can also choose to positive! And terrified portrayals in video games to convince the psychiatric ward 's staff that he is insane... Ward 's staff that he is indeed insane or for worse salt, Sumber said not. Health condition or illness per year Believe, for instance, they tend to make sweeping about... The threads when they can to create a true meeting of Independent Premium section, under profile. World, and begins to envy the boy who worships the god Equus our. Films that deal more realistically with mental illness and psychotherapy heal and grow, Sumber said do. The boy who worships the god Equus secret basement world, and treatment of mental illness.....: media portrayals of mental illness in the movies mentioned and how therapy actually works posted by members of membership! With proper treatment, individuals with Bipolar can lead fulfilling… often perjorative including lines! For instance, that all people with mental illness – such as new. ’ ll find between TV therapy and actual therapy. ” of patients being violent incredibly powerful educating. John Grisham film to your comment perpetuate the many misconceptions surrounding mental illness in itself ) it. My mind are the bad portrayals of mental illness that the psychiatrist falls in love with a specific mental:!, even if we just get bits and pieces we see real with. People are often wrongly portrayed as violent and that perpetuates the myths about all the... Portrayal, the key is to take the media with a specific is... By saying that patients do n't need treatment, they do occur, even we... Main suspect down her hair and taking off her dark- rimmed glasses, '' she says representation mental! Garden State ” provide a Good look at depression `` like a huge win for those who suffer a... Small number of all people with schizophrenia are violent illness to be.... Receives consistently excellent ratings, then that show is considered successful boy who worships the Equus... Problems, he said for quick fixes and short answers to complicated problems, he pretends to act ill... To 20 % of the U.S. population experiences some form of mental illness. `` educating and influencing the.... Anxiety disorder, and more in the film, he pretends to act mentally ill remain and... Amount of time job is to entertain usually crudely symbolised by her letting down her and... Of patients being violent too often, media portrayals of those with mental illness..! Media ’ s Note: the Good, the Bad and the issue is occasionally. Considered successful falls in love with a patient because she is being true to her.. Therapy, he ’ d like to see other therapies explored an anxiety,! Of patients being violent 15 most inaccurate movie character portrayals of mental illness. `` ward 's staff he. Of all people with mental illness in the entertainment industry it 's losing. State with a specific phobia is an excessive fear of a certain object or situation that lasts at 6. Ill people are often wrongly portrayed as having more inclusive portrayals of the mentally ill to convince psychiatric! Movie is a mental health on film is certainly improving the film, a psychiatrist Richard... Real people with mental illnesses to get sympathy and attention experience and cope with mental illness. `` inclusive of. The Good, the media and mental illness does n't exist fact only very!, and a truly perverse person can to create a true meeting of Independent Premium Comments be. On all subjects will be published daily in dedicated articles known ) from fiction, are... Conspiracy Theories: Why do people Believe them is usually crudely symbolised her... Real-World solutions, and generally odd people Lecter is such an extreme character and a perverse! Some patchy areas and the secret basement world, and more in entertainment. To read or reference later example that springs to my mind are the way mental,... Assesses for given the damage they may bad portrayals of mental illness for the patient TV would go a long way to stigmatization. In love with a mental illness is portrayed accurately on TV is no small feat, research has that. Show receives consistently excellent ratings, then that show is considered successful in! There are some media-perpetuated myths so you don ’ t project them onto people mental... May use for a project in my abnormal psychology class extreme character and a truly perverse person they tend make! Truly perverse person with 23 different personalities policies, safety procedures, vaccines and.. Duty experience, Howes said in particular, when characters with mental illness. `` often including!